MenomoneeFallsNOW.com
search all things local
     
Blog Home |  Email Author  |        Welcome to MyCommunityNOW - Blogs Sign in | Join

Brookfield Wannabe

Roxanne Suson, a Brookfield native and graduate of Brookfield East High School, provides readers with an eclectic mix of topics. Once a trial attorney, now a full-time mom, Roxanne blogs about the happiness, sadness, and absurdity of life and family in the suburbs.

The Other Edwards

By Roxanne Suson
Friday, Aug 8 2008, 05:43 PM

By now, you may have read that John Edwards, after vehemently denying tabloid reports of an affair, has admitted that it is true and that it occurred during the time that his wife has been battling cancer.  What a ***. 

I reacted strongly to the admission because I read Elizabeth Edwards autobiography, Saving Graces, last fall, and I found it to be one of the most touching and powerful books that I have read in recent memory.  The original book was published in 2006, when it appeared that her breast cancer had fallen into remission.  A postscript chapter, published in 2007, revealed that the cancer had returned, had spread to her bones, and was now classified as incurable.

I don't know her, but she seems like a remarkable lady based on what she's been through:  the death of her first son in 1996, birth of twins after infertility treatment while in her 40s, breast cancer diagnosis with two young children, and then incurable bone cancer.

Despite all that, she managed to write an extraordinary, even uplifting, book.  Her text resonates with grace, strength, and dignity.

Elizabeth Edwards: a class act.    John Edwards: Not so much.
 

Comments

Richard J. Steinberg   

I was impressed that our website was to comment on local issues that our residents and readers should be aware of. Your comments join other national politico writers who think they need to weigh in on every scandal. Enough of that. You are a good enough writer to give out some positive advice.

August 8, 2008 8:15 PM

Richard J. Steinberg   

Why do you have to weigh in on national politics ? There are enough issues that affect our local taxpayers to comment on. Lets keep our website non-partisan.

August 8, 2008 8:22 PM

kathryn   

I didn't take Ms Suson's remarks to be political or scandal-mongering.  Perhaps it reflects a gender difference.  This incident will resonate with a lot of women.

August 8, 2008 10:10 PM

Roxanne Suson    

My blog is not a comment on national politics nor do I believe that it is "partisan."  It is a comment on a man who cheated on his wife while she was battling cancer, a woman I came to admire while reading her book.  Am I bashing John Edwards?  Yes, but not because of his politics.

I have been writing my blog since BrookfieldNow first started two years ago, and I am in fact one of the original 18 bloggers that kicked off the NOW sites.  Early on, I made a decision to avoid blogging about local politics/taxpayer issues because there were many other bloggers who covered those topics. (Cindy Kilkenny, Robert Flessas, Shawn Matson, Kyle Prast -- to name a few bloggers past and present)  So, I decided to give Brookfield readers something different.

This blog has always and will continue to be a mix of topics, some local and some not.

August 8, 2008 10:11 PM

Larry Knetzger   

Hi Roxanne, I enjoy the varied subjects that you offer your point of view on and appreciate the fact that you do express your opinion in a fashion that I like. So keep up the fine job. Local or other wise subjects make for interesting discussion. Thank you.

P. S. The Edwards story really underlines the fact that the private sector is so skeptical of politicians or others that are in public view and so sometimes the voting system does work and people have the opportunity to change by using their vote to express satisfaction or lack of satisfaction. At times it has been successful here in Brookfield. i. e. new Municipal Judge.

August 9, 2008 9:49 AM

Richard J. Steinberg   

I agree that the substance of the story about Edwards is newsworthy but there are other scandals that deserve the same scrutiny and have been selectively chosen by the professional media. The laundry list is long and our wonderful community deserves higher standards. The first amendment is a freedom to cherish.

August 9, 2008 11:32 AM

Cindy   

Oh, Roxanne. I'd reconsider that "wannabee" thing. Maybe life is pretty good where you are now! Brookfield is downright weird sometimes.

I suppose John Edwards would find himself right at home. Politicians with a gal on the side are nothing new here.

August 10, 2008 10:10 AM

IMNOTPC   

Like you said, Judge, the first amendment is a freedom to cherish. Roxanne has very right to expose John Edwards for what he really is. The irony regarding this story is that blogs and talk radio are the only forms of media covering it. You get upset that "your guy" is being exposed, but I am sure it would be front page news if the guy was a conservative. I appreciate Roxanne for contributing to making ALL newsworthy stories available to the public.  

August 10, 2008 12:38 PM

Richard J. Steinberg   

Pursuant to the Code of Judicial Ethics Municipal Judges are non-partisan and we strictly adhere to that rule. There are enough local issues and problems to be discussed and resolved within our own community that take positive thinking.

August 11, 2008 10:41 AM

IMNOTPC   

Sometimes, a negative must be revealed in order to paint the true picture of a person. If a politician gets positive coverage all the time, the public is being deceived.

Every issue has two sides, and just because you focus on a negative aspect of an issue, it does not mean that you're not thinking positively. Take ethanol mandates for instance. I could debate all the negative aspects of ethanol fuel with politicians. If, for some reason they listened and backed off on ethanol, I think a positive just occurred. See my point?

August 11, 2008 5:13 PM

Tom Gehl   

A story does not need to be directly related to our community in order to be relevant to our communty, or of interest to it.  And certainly some of your posts Judge Steinberg, have dealt with matters completely unrelated to Brookfield or S.E. Wisconin.  And that's great.  If every post from every blogger was focused on our local area and its issues, it would get pretty boring pretty fast.

August 20, 2008 5:41 AM

St. John Vianney   

In defense of Judge Steinberg, as bloggers representing the Brookfield N Now website, we have been asked when we signed up to keep the blogs "local".  It's okay to comment from time to time on national issues, but remember that what makes the Brookfield Now site so unique is the local flavor and commentary from the residents.  We all represent a unique "voice" of Brookfield (and its BORDERS - in fairness to Roxanne).  I enjoy Roxanne's writing and her take on Elizabeth Edwards.  But My Community/Brookfield Now bloggers need to remember why we are here in the first place and, with that in mind, the Judge has a point.  

August 20, 2008 8:04 PM

Leave a Comment

Please Sign In to post comment.